The Chart Make-Over Challenge of 2009
As I mentioned in a previous article, I attended the Open Government conference in DC. If you followed my tweets that day, you might remember this one:
If you have to tell the audience in the back that it’ll be hard to read your chart, you’ve got a poorly designed chart. #ogi#ppt
Well, here is the slide in question. It was presented by Aneesh Chopra, the new federal Chief Technology Officer. Though well intentioned, the chart was impossible to read or absorb as a member of the audience.
Your challenge:
Redesign the slide to the right so that the information is more readable and, of course, more effectively reinforces the speaker’s message. To participate:
- Redesign the chart slide to the right as one or more slides in PowerPoint, Keynote, or Impress (OpenOffice)
- Post your submission on SlideShare. Please add the keyword of “cc09″ and submit it to the Chart Make-Over Challenge 2009 group.
- If you also blog about it, feel free to comment below with a link or email me the link at webmaster@mike-pulsifer.org and I’ll post a brief summary here.
The deadline is Noon EST on Sunday, August 16. I’ll link to each submission here shortly after the deadline.
Of course, no chart is any good without the context in which it is presented. You can watch the recorded presentation at this link (discussion of this chart starts at about 1:50). For your convenience, a transcript of the relevant portion is below:
Let me be begin with just a phenomenal story about our personal lives. This is a difficult to see graphic for those in the back, but it conveys a very powerful message. This time in our life, we are seeing a tremendous increase in the adoption rate of new technologies. The graphic before you shows how long it took the average American household to adopt an innovation. And you can see over the 30s and 40s as we adopted refrigerators and washing machines and so forth. It took some time. The slope of the S-curve, as they say is growing but not as steep as in the current era. In fact, we’re seeing the adoption of cellphones as an example exceeding those of homes with dishwashers. In fact, if you think about the context, there will be newer and newer services and products that emerge the year post this evaluation, you’ll see the same rapidity. At the same time, we’ll acknowledge we’re at the infancy of this digital era.
Aneesh Chopra – Federal CTO






Comments
Comment from Jan Schultink
Time August 3, 2009 at 9:12 pm
Hi Mike, nice challenge. Not sure whether I can fit the deadline in though. Just in case, do you have the actual data behind the lines in an Excel file?
Comment from WVMikeP
Time August 4, 2009 at 3:48 am
I don't have the raw data, but I'll surely try to come up with
something this evening.
Comment from Ed Kavanagh
Time August 10, 2009 at 4:09 am
Not sure that slideshare group page is working properly, here is my entry
http://www.slideshare.net/edfk/adopt-this
Pingback from Chart Make-Over Challenge Wrap-Up – Thoughts On Presenting And Design
Time August 17, 2009 at 9:02 pm
[...] couple weeks ago, I issued a challenge: redesign a chart slide that was of little to no use of any audience member in the back of the [...]